Sme li se doliti ulje drugačijeg viskoziteta? 5W-30, 5W-40 i druge kombinacije - Slika 1
Back to blog
Published: 16 November 2026
10 min read

Can You Top Up with a Different Oil Viscosity? 5W-30, 5W-40 and Other Combinations

The dipstick shows the minimum level, but the petrol station does not stock your usual oil. There is 5W-40 on the shelf, while your engine contains 5W-30. Or perhaps there is 10W-40, and you do not know what the manufacturer originally specified.

Ask the same question on an online forum and you will get every answer imaginable, from “It makes no difference, just pour it in” to “Your engine is finished”. The truth is less dramatic than either.

 

QUICK ANSWER

In most cases, you can top up with a small amount of engine oil of a different viscosity, particularly if it meets the same specification required by your vehicle manufacturer. However, mixing oils should not become a habit. Always give preference to the oil specified for your engine, and consider an earlier oil change if you have added a larger amount of a different oil.

 

What Happens When You Mix 5W-30 and 5W-40?

The first number, followed by W, describes how the oil behaves during a cold start. The second indicates its viscosity at engine operating temperature. Oils labelled 5W-30 and 5W-40 have the same winter grade, but differ in how “thick” they are when the engine is hot. We explain exactly what the markings on the container mean, and why the specification matters more than the viscosity, in our guide to topping up engine oil [internal link: /blog/dolivanje-ulja-u-motor-sta-je-zaista-vazno].

Three things happen when you mix them:

■      The oils mix physically without difficulty. API-licensed engine oils must pass a standardised homogeneity and miscibility test, partly because drivers often do not know exactly which oil is already in the engine. The mixture does not separate or congeal.

■      The viscosity of the mixture ends up somewhere between the two oils, closer to whichever oil makes up the larger share. If you add half a litre of 5W-40 to an engine containing four litres of 5W-30, the resulting blend remains very close to the oil already in the engine.

■      The blend is no longer a product that has been tested as such. Each oil has its own additive package. When two packages are mixed, the result is no longer identical to either original oil. TotalEnergies states that mixing oils with similar properties is generally not a problem, but the final performance of the blend cannot be guaranteed. The same applies to approvals: manufacturer approvals relate to specific oil formulations, so mixing two products does not automatically mean that the blend retains all their declared performance characteristics and approvals.

The Most Common Oil Combinations

■      5W-30 + 5W-30 from another brand: generally acceptable. Both oils should meet the same ACEA category and carry the same vehicle manufacturer approval.

■      5W-30 + 5W-40: acceptable in an emergency. The winter grade is the same, while the blend will be slightly more viscous at operating temperature. If the owner’s manual permits both viscosity grades, the difference is practically negligible.

■      5W-30 + 10W-40: greater caution is needed, especially in winter. Both the winter grade and the operating-temperature grade differ, and many oils of this viscosity are intended for older engines without particulate filters.

■      0W-20 + 5W-30: only if the owner’s manual allows it. Some Toyota manuals permit the use of 5W-30 when 0W-20 is unavailable, provided you return to 0W-20 at the next oil change. This does not apply to every engine.

■      Synthetic + mineral or semi-synthetic oil: a temporary solution. They can be mixed physically, but the blend loses some of the benefits of synthetic oil and its performance cannot be guaranteed.

Specifications: Where Drivers Really Go Wrong

Viscosity is what drivers tend to look at; the specification is what the engine requires. There are three common mistakes.

ACEA C is not the same as ACEA A/B. ACEA C oils have a reduced content of sulphated ash, phosphorus and sulphur (low- or mid-SAPS) and are intended for engines with particulate filters (DPF in diesel engines and GPF in petrol engines). A single small top-up with an unsuitable oil is unlikely to cause immediate damage to the DPF, but repeated use can contribute to faster filter blockage.

Not all ACEA C categories are interchangeable. ACEA C3 is not automatically a suitable substitute for C2 or C5. The categories have different requirements, including viscosity at high temperature and high shear. Choose the exact ACEA category specified by your vehicle manufacturer. The words “ACEA C” on a container are not enough.

Manufacturer approval means more than viscosity. Codes such as VW 504 00 / 507 00, MB 229.51 or BMW Longlife-04 indicate that the vehicle manufacturer has tested the complete oil formulation. Extended (long-life) service intervals are based on such oils. In modern turbocharged direct-injection petrol engines, the specification also helps protect against low-speed pre-ignition (LSPI). Newer API categories, including API SP and, since 2025, API SQ, were introduced in part to address that risk.

 

AUTOKONEKT

Not sure which oil is right for your car? Choosing the wrong oil can cost more than a routine oil change. Find a verified garage through AutoKonekt, check the correct oil specification and book an oil and filter change online.

Find a garage and book an appointment: autokonekt.rs  ›

 

How Much of a Different Oil Counts as “a Little”?

As a rule of thumb for an emergency top-up using oil with different characteristics, TotalEnergies recommends a quantity of around ten per cent of the total oil system capacity. For many passenger-car engines, this is approximately half a litre. This is not a universal safe limit; it is a guideline intended to reduce risk. Nothing changes abruptly at 450 or 550 ml. The principle is simple: the greater the proportion of different oil, the further the blend moves away from what the engine was meant to use, and the stronger the case for an earlier oil change.

One important point: a single oil-level reading does not tell you how quickly the engine is consuming oil. You also need to know how many kilometres have been driven since the previous check. If you have to top up frequently, or the level drops unusually quickly, have the cause investigated by a garage. We discuss acceptable oil consumption in our guide to topping up engine oil [internal link: /blog/dolivanje-ulja-u-motor-sta-je-zaista-vazno].

Myth: Thicker Oil Protects the Engine Better

This is probably one of the most common pieces of advice heard in garages and on forums: “Use thicker oil. The engine is older, so it will protect it better.”

Higher viscosity does not, by itself, mean poorer lubrication. Problems arise when an oil does not match the engine’s design, operating conditions or manufacturer specification. Modern engines also use oil as a hydraulic fluid in hydraulic valve lifters, timing-chain tensioners and variable valve timing systems. These components are designed for a particular viscosity range. TotalEnergies also warns that thicker oil at high operating temperatures may be less effective at carrying heat away from piston rings and turbocharger bearings.

Thicker oil is therefore not automatically better protection. Only change viscosity within the range permitted by the owner’s manual, or on the advice of a mechanic who has inspected the engine.

Low Oil Level Is Not the Same as an Oil-Pressure Warning

This distinction is more important than anything else in this article.

An oil level at the minimum mark or a low-oil-level warning (yellow on many vehicles) means you should top up as soon as possible. If the specified oil is unavailable, consult the owner’s manual or a garage before selecting a substitute. In a genuine emergency, adding a small amount of oil that differs from the recommendation may be less risky than continuing to drive with a dangerously low oil level, but it does not guarantee the engine’s safety.

A red oil-pressure warning light while driving is a different situation. It may mean the lubrication system is not working correctly. Stop safely as soon as possible and switch off the engine. Do not try to “make it to the garage”. If the warning remains on even when the oil level is correct, do not continue driving.

 

AUTOKONEKT LOCATIONS

Oil-pressure warning light staying on? Do not risk driving to a garage. Use the AutoKonekt partner map to find a towing service and a verified garage in your town or city.

autokonekt.rs/lokacije  ›

 

What to Do After Topping Up with a Different Oil

First, make a note of what oil you added and how much. The easiest way is to photograph the container, because your mechanic will need that information at the next oil change. What to do next depends on the situation:

■      Small amount, same specification, different viscosity: continue driving as normal until the scheduled oil change, and check the oil level a little more often.

■      Small amount, different or unknown specification: arrange an earlier oil and filter change, particularly if the engine has a particulate filter.

■      Larger amount of a different oil: change the oil and filter earlier. You do not necessarily have to visit a garage immediately, but do not wait for the full service interval.

■      Vehicle with extended (long-life) service intervals: the vehicle’s service-interval system is calculated for the specified oil, not an unverified blend. After a larger top-up with a different oil, the full interval can no longer be relied upon in the same way.

■      Vehicle under warranty: keep the receipt and tell the garage what was added. It is better to record and correct a deviation than to discover it later.

■      Unusual symptoms after topping up (warning light, noisy hydraulic lifters, smoke from the exhaust): have the vehicle checked immediately, regardless of the quantity added.

The Difference Matters Most in Winter

During a cold start, oil is at its thickest just when the engine needs it most, while the pump is still circulating oil through the passages. This is when the first number in the viscosity grade really matters. If, before winter, you have added a larger amount of oil with a higher first number (for example, 10W to an engine requiring 0W or 5W), changing the oil before the first frosts is a sensible precaution.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I add 5W-40 if my engine contains 5W-30?

Yes, in an emergency and in a small amount, provided the specification is the same. If the manual permits both viscosity grades, the difference is practically negligible.

Can I add 10W-40 to 5W-30?

Only in an emergency, in a small amount, and after checking the specification. If you have added more than half a litre, consider an earlier oil change.

Does the blend retain the vehicle manufacturer’s approval?

You cannot assume that it does, because approval applies to a specific formulation. Compliance with the requirements has simply not been verified for the blend.

I added oil without a low-SAPS designation to a diesel engine with a DPF. What now?

Immediate damage to the filter is unlikely, but do not run this blend for the full service interval. Arrange an earlier oil change using the ACEA category specified by the manufacturer.

Can I use ACEA C3 instead of C2 or C5?

Not automatically, because the categories have different requirements. Use the category and manufacturer approval specified in your vehicle’s manual.

Do I need to change the oil immediately after mixing?

No, if you have added a small quantity of oil meeting the same specification. In other cases, arrange an oil change before the normal service interval.

In Summary

A small amount of oil with a different viscosity is rarely a problem. The wrong specification, especially in engines with particulate filters and extended service intervals, is a bigger problem than it might appear. When choosing oil for a top-up, read the back of the container, not just the front. And the simplest solution fits in the boot: a one-litre bottle of your usual engine oil.

Related article: Topping Up Engine Oil: What Really Matters [internal link: /blog/dolivanje-ulja-u-motor-sta-je-zaista-vazno]